I just read a review in Time Magazine by Christopher Hitchens (author of “God is Not Great”) on the new book “Mother Teresa: Come Be My Light”. It is a mean spirited review, although I am thankful for his honesty. By actually criticizing Mother Theresa and religion he is dignifying it by not marginalizing it.
Here are some reflections on Mother Teresa’s struggle with doubt.
I admire her determined commitment to Jesus even though she didn’t feel his presence for forty years. The doubts began just a few months after she’d started the Sisters of Mercy in 1958 and stayed with her, unabated, until her death. It is a testimony to her pure, raw faith. I also commend her for sharing these doubts with spiritual advisors. That is, she didn’t try to fight the battle on her own.
But I am struck by how badly she and her mentors handled her doubts. As I share my concerns, please keep in mind that I have been and continue to be a great admirer of her life. She was, without question, one of the great witnesses to Jesus in the 20th century, the Roman Catholic counter part to Billy Graham. I love her raw courage at Harvard where after receiving a sustained standing ovation she said to our country’s current and future elites, “Give me your babies. Don’t abort them.” Few have the faith not to live in the presence of and bow to our cultural elites. I praise God for her life and witness to the gospel.
1. Romanticism. Mother Teresa and her mentors handled her doubts at a purely emotional level. Oprah and Rousseau (18th century romantic) would be pleased. What do I mean? She doesn’t think about the doubts. She just tries to suppress them or get rid of them. When she doubts God’s existence, she doesn’t do battle at a rational level. This is the lingering influence of an early Romantic tendency in Medieval Church piety that strongly emphasized the affective, feeling side of knowing Jesus but neglected the rational side. The rational side was taken up by Medieval Scholastics such as Anselm and Aquinas, but the two tended not to meet.
What would this look like? If she doubts God’s existence, soak herself in creation. Read a book on The Big Bang Theory and see how closely it matches Genesis 1. Reading Michael Behe’s book “Darwin’s Black Box.” Soak her mind with the truth of God as revealed in creation. Thomas Aquinas (medieval philosopher and scholastic) encouraged this with his formulation of the Cosmological Argument. Read Charles Malik’s book, “The Wonder of Being”. I think I’ve read that book three times in the last 30 years. He is a Greek Orthodox philosopher and diplomat. It saved my soul in college. I find his critique of Kant brilliant. He basically says that if you begin with wonder at creation and the miracle of existence instead of trying to establish a criteria for knowing that you come easily to God. If you become like a child and just see, if you don’t try to be something you are not…that is if you stop trying to be God, then you will see God. Isn’t that awesome?
The same is true when she doubts Jesus is God. She doesn’t sit and reflect on all that she knows and loves about Jesus. She collapses in the face of the doubt. She just goes into her Romantic foxhole and endures a pummeling. I don’t mean to be mean by saying “Romantic foxhole”. I’m just trying to capture in a short phrase the weakness of a purely affective response to evil. You need to think. Paul says in II Corinthians 10 to “take every thought captive”. How do you take something captive? Teresa only does the first step.
a. You identify it. Teresa does that.
b. You develop a plan to get it. Doesn’t do that.
c. You attack it. Thinking. Reason. Wisdom. Books. Massive Prayer.
d. You capture it. In other words, you keep at attacking until you win.
2. The World. She handles her doubts as though they were strange. She and we live in the most aggressively atheistic culture that has ever existed. In our PrayerLife seminar I mention how strange it is that Dan Rather didn’t open the evening news with prayer. In the roughly 100,000 known cultures (a wild guess) that have existed in the history of humanity, ours is the only one to not publicly acknowledge the existence of a spiritual world. That is weird. Everyone living in the 20th and 21st century breathes the air of unbelief. It would be strange to NOT have problems with doubt given how pervasive functional atheism is of our culture. For example, if I told you that I lived in Las Vegas and worked on the Strip and I was having problems with sexual lust, you would NOT think that was strange. In fact, if you knew I was going to work on the Strip, you’d likely say, “Can I pray for you? It must be rough out there.”
3. Public Prayer. Teresa appears to be weak in her application of prayer to her life. That is, she isn’t regularly asking people to pray for her faith. I think a Christian leader needs to be doing that on a regular basis. That is the foundation of the work. If that falls, everything falls. Paul the Apostle is regularly praying for the church’s faith. Read I Thessalonians 1, 2, and 3 through this window. Paul is in the throes of childbirth (his image) for the faith of the Thessalonians. He finally can’t stand not knowing and sends Timothy “to find out about there faith”. Almost every letter of Paul’s begins with describing how he is praying for their faith.
4. Repentance. Possibly, more was involved in this than I’m aware, but I don’t see her mentors or her reflecting on her heart, on doors that she might have left open for Satan. Hitchins even brings this up. He mentions her considerable self-will. It is hard to find a strong leader who doesn’t struggle with self-will. He was struck by the pattern of her strong will to begin Sisters of Mercy and then once it was started the doubts kicked in. Did self-will in Teresa’s life open the door to Satan? I don’t see her making those kind of heart connections. Satan goes through doors that we open for him.
5. The Gospel. I wish I could have taken Teresa through the Sonship course. In other words, I wish she’d been exposed to the Reformation. The gospel applied to the heart is a great cure for doubting God’s love for you. “Preach the Gospel to yourself” was one of the phrases we used in the Sonship course. In other words, meditate on the finished work of Christ even though you don’t feel it. That was the great Reformation discovery that grace is imputed to us not because we’ve arrived at the right emotional state but because of the blood of Jesus.
If you are reading this, would you pray for my faith, and the faith of the Christian leaders that you know, that they would have a simple, pure devotion to Christ?